Examining the impact of the number of regions used in cluster detection methods: An application to childhood asthma visits to a hospital in Manitoba, Canada

  • Mahmoud Torabi | Mahmoud.Torabi@umanitoba.ca Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada.
  • Katie Galloway Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada.

Abstract

The level of spatial aggregation is a major concern in cluster investigations. Combining regions to protect privacy may result in a loss of power and thus, can limit the information researchers can obtain. The impact of spatial aggregation on the ability to detect clusters is examined in this study, which shows the importance of choosing the correct level of spatial aggregation in cluster investigations. We applied the circular spatial scan statistic (CSS), flexible spatial scan statistic (FSS) and Bayesian disease mapping (BYM) approaches to a dataset containing childhood asthma visits to a hospital in Manitoba, Canada, using three different levels of spatial aggregation. Specifically, we used 56, 67 and 220 regions in the analysis, respectively. It is expected that the three scenarios will yield different results and will highlight the importance of using the right level of spatial aggregation. The three methods (CSS, FSS, BYM) examined in this study performed similarly when detecting potential clusters. However, for different levels of spatial aggregation, the potential clusters identified were different. As the number of regions used in the analysis increased, the total area identified in the cluster decreased. In general, potential clusters were identified in the central and northern parts of Manitoba. Overall, it is crucial to identify the appropriate number of regions to study spatial patterns of disease as it directly affects the results and consequently the conclusions. Additional investigation through future work is needed to determine which scenario of spatial aggregation is best.

Dimensions

Altmetric

PlumX Metrics

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
Published
2018-11-09
Info
Issue
Section
Original Articles
Keywords:
Asthma, Bayesian computation, Geographic epidemiology, Spatial aggregation, Spatial cluster detection
Statistics
  • Abstract views: 720

  • PDF: 306
  • APPENDIX: 150
  • HTML: 10
How to Cite
Torabi, M., & Galloway, K. (2018). Examining the impact of the number of regions used in cluster detection methods: An application to childhood asthma visits to a hospital in Manitoba, Canada. Geospatial Health, 13(2). https://doi.org/10.4081/gh.2018.696